Cybernion
← Insights

United States

CMMC vs IRAP Compared

30 Aug 2026 · Updated 30 Aug 2026

CMMC and IRAP both give government confidence in a supplier, but they work differently. CMMC is a pass/fail certification a US defence contractor must hold to win contracts. IRAP is an independent assessment of a system against the Australian Information Security Manual, which the agency then risk-accepts. There is no IRAP certificate. For a defence supplier, CMMC is most like Australia’s DISP membership, with IRAP as the system assessment on top.

A supplier that provides defence services in both the US and Australia will meet CMMC in one and IRAP and DISP in the other. The three are often assumed to be equivalents. They are not, and mistaking one for the other leads to the wrong preparation.

What is the difference between CMMC and IRAP?

The fundamental difference is what each produces. CMMC is a US Department of Defense certification that a defence contractor must hold to be awarded relevant contracts, assessed as pass or fail against NIST 800-171 by a certified third party assessor or the government. IRAP is an Australian program in which an ASD endorsed assessor independently assesses a system against the Information Security Manual and produces a report.

CMMC (US) IRAP (Australia)
Output A certification at a defined level An assessment report against the ISM
Who decides The certification gates contract eligibility The consuming agency authorises the system
Assessed against NIST SP 800-171 (and 800-172 at Level 3) The Information Security Manual
Assessed by Certified third party assessor or the government An ASD endorsed IRAP assessor
Central list Yes, certification status No central authorised list

The two do the same broad job, giving government confidence in a supplier or system, but through different mechanisms. That difference drives everything about how an organisation prepares for each.

Is CMMC a certification and IRAP an assessment?

Yes, and getting this distinction right matters more than any other point. CMMC results in a certification at a defined level, and holding that certification is what makes a contractor eligible for the relevant US defence contracts. It is a pass or fail outcome tied to contract award.

IRAP does not produce a certification. An IRAP assessment produces a report describing how a system meets the controls of the Information Security Manual, including its strengths, weaknesses and residual risks. The Australian agency that consumes the system then makes its own decision to authorise it to operate, based on that report and its own risk appetite. There is no IRAP certificate, and there is no central authorised list of IRAP assessed systems the way there is for CMMC certification or FedRAMP authorization. This is the single most common misunderstanding among companies moving between the two systems: they expect an IRAP certificate to present, and it does not exist. What exists is an assessment report and an agency authorisation decision.

Which is closer to CMMC, IRAP or DISP?

For a defence supplier, the Defence Industry Security Program, known as DISP, is closer to CMMC than IRAP is. Both CMMC and DISP are gates on a contractor’s eligibility to do defence work, tied to the organisation rather than a specific system. A company joins DISP to be eligible for Australian defence work, in a way that parallels holding CMMC certification to be eligible for US defence work.

IRAP operates at a different level. It assesses a specific system against the Information Security Manual, rather than certifying the organisation as a whole. So the cleaner mental model for a defence supplier is that CMMC maps most closely to DISP membership as the eligibility gate, and IRAP maps to the system level security assessment that applies on top when a system holds government information. A US defence contractor entering the Australian market should therefore not look for an IRAP equivalent of CMMC, but should look at DISP for the eligibility gate and IRAP for the system assessment. The two together cover the ground that CMMC covers on the US side.

What should a defence supplier operating in both countries do?

Treat the two regimes as separate and prepare for each on its own terms. For the US, implement NIST 800-171 in full and pursue the CMMC level the contract requires, through the appropriate self-assessment or third party certification. For Australia, obtain DISP membership as the eligibility gate, and plan for an IRAP assessment of any system that holds Australian government information, at the right classification.

The good news is that the underlying technical controls overlap substantially. NIST 800-171 and the Information Security Manual both require sound access control, patching, multi-factor authentication and configuration management, so a contractor that has properly implemented one has done much of the technical work for the other, as covered in NIST 800-171 vs the Essential Eight. What does not carry across is the certification and assessment itself: CMMC certification is not accepted for Australian work, and an IRAP assessment is not accepted for US work. So the sensible approach is a shared technical control baseline, with the country specific certifications, memberships and assessments built on top. For the Australian side, we help through IRAP assessment and readiness and the Essential Eight baseline.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between CMMC and IRAP?

CMMC is a US Department of Defense certification that a defence contractor must hold to be awarded relevant contracts, assessed as pass or fail against NIST 800-171 by a third party or the government. IRAP is an Australian program in which an endorsed assessor independently assesses a system against the Information Security Manual and produces a report, which the consuming agency uses to make its own authorisation decision. One is a certification, the other an assessment.

Is CMMC a certification and IRAP an assessment?

Yes, and this is the key difference. CMMC results in a certification at a defined level, which gates eligibility for US defence contracts. IRAP does not produce a certification, an IRAP assessment produces a report on how a system meets the Information Security Manual, and the Australian agency that consumes the system decides whether to authorise it. There is no IRAP certificate and no central authorised list the way CMMC works.

Which is closer to CMMC, IRAP or DISP?

The Defence Industry Security Program (DISP) is closer to CMMC than IRAP is. Both CMMC and DISP are membership or certification gates on defence work, tied to a contractor’s eligibility. IRAP, by contrast, assesses a specific system against the Information Security Manual rather than certifying the organisation. So a defence supplier moving between the US and Australia should think of CMMC as most like DISP membership, with IRAP as the system level assessment on top.

Does CMMC apply in Australia?

No. CMMC is a US Department of Defense requirement and does not apply to Australian government or defence work. An Australian company only needs CMMC if it is in the US defence supply chain handling US Controlled Unclassified Information. For Australian defence work, the equivalent gates are Defence Industry Security Program membership and, for systems holding government information, an IRAP assessment against the Information Security Manual.

What should a defence supplier operating in both countries do?

Treat the two regimes as separate. For the US, implement NIST 800-171 and pursue the required CMMC level. For Australia, obtain Defence Industry Security Program membership as the eligibility gate and plan for IRAP assessment of systems that hold government information. The underlying technical controls overlap, so the work is not fully duplicated, but the certifications and assessments are separate and neither satisfies the other.


Written by Gaurav Vikash, an ASD endorsed IRAP assessor and senior cyber security leader with 18 years of experience across Australia, the UK and Asia, including CISO and senior security leadership roles. He holds CISSP, CISA, CISM and CRISC and is an ISO 27001 Lead Auditor and ISO 42001 Lead Implementer, and speaks regularly at industry conferences.

Talk to us.

Sources:

  1. Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification (CMMC) Program, Federal Register, 15 October 2024
  2. Infosec Registered Assessors Program (IRAP), Australian Signals Directorate, 2026
  3. Defence Industry Security Program, Department of Defence, 2026
  4. Information Security Manual, Australian Signals Directorate, 2026

Last updated: 30 August, 2026

Talk to us about your engagement

A scoped proposal within one business day.