State Government
IS18 vs VPDSS vs SACSF: State Frameworks Compared
30 Aug 2026 · Updated 30 Aug 2026
Queensland’s IS18, Victoria’s VPDSS and South Australia’s SACSF protect government information in three quite different ways. IS18 runs on an ISO 27001 management system with the Essential Eight mandated. The VPDSS is twelve outcome based standards under privacy law. The SACSF is eighteen policy statements inside a protective security framework. None fixes an Essential Eight maturity level, and each reports on its own cadence.
Three states, three philosophies. For an organisation working across Queensland, Victoria and South Australia, the differences between these frameworks are more instructive than their similarities, because they show how differently governments can approach the same problem.
What is the difference between IS18, the VPDSS and the SACSF?
The three frameworks differ in structure, legal basis and philosophy. Queensland’s IS18 is built around an ISO 27001 information security management system with the Essential Eight mandated. Victoria’s VPDSS is a set of twelve outcome based standards issued under privacy legislation. South Australia’s SACSF is eighteen policy statements grouped under four protective security principles.
| Queensland IS18 | Victoria VPDSS | South Australia SACSF | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Structure | Five requirements, ISO 27001 ISMS | Twelve standards, outcome based | Eighteen statements, four principles |
| Legal basis | QGEA policy, under public sector and financial law | Privacy and Data Protection Act 2014 | Under the SA Protective Security Framework |
| Administered by | Cyber Security Unit (Customer and Digital Group) | Office of the Victorian Information Commissioner | Cyber Security Directorate (Treasury and Finance) |
| Essential Eight | Mandated, level set by risk | Not mandated | Reported, no set level |
| Reporting | Annual return, 30 September | Biennial security plan plus attestation | Annual attestation |
The common thread is the goal, protecting government information, and a shared respect for ISO 27001. The divergence is in how each state gets there.
How do IS18, VPDSS and SACSF treat the Essential Eight?
None of the three fixes an Essential Eight maturity floor, which is the single clearest thing they share and the clearest difference from New South Wales and Western Australia. But they treat the Essential Eight differently within that.
Queensland’s IS18 mandates that agencies implement the Essential Eight, but leaves the target maturity to a risk assessment rather than naming a level. Victoria’s VPDSS does not mandate the Essential Eight at all; its model is outcome based and anchored to ISO 27001, so an agency meets the ICT security standard however its risk assessment directs, which may or may not use the Essential Eight. South Australia’s SACSF falls in between: agencies report their Essential Eight maturity in the annual attestation, but the framework states explicitly that there is no expectation they reach a set level. So across the three, the Essential Eight is mandated without a level in Queensland, optional in Victoria, and measured but not mandated in South Australia. The way every state treats the Essential Eight is compared in which states mandate the Essential Eight.
How do reporting and attestation compare across IS18, VPDSS and SACSF?
All three put a senior officer’s signature behind an assessment, but the cadence and recipient differ. Queensland’s IS18 requires an annual information security return by 30 September, with the accountable officer attesting to the agency’s posture, reflected in the annual report.
Victoria’s VPDSS runs on a longer cycle: a biennial Protective Data Security Plan submitted to the Office of the Victorian Information Commissioner, with an annual attestation in the intervening years and an out of cycle submission on significant change. South Australia’s SACSF requires an annual attestation, collated by the Department of Treasury and Finance into a report for the senior leadership and Cabinet. So Queensland and South Australia are annual, Victoria is biennial with a lighter annual check, and each reports to a different central body, a cyber security unit, an information commissioner, and a treasury department respectively. A supplier or an agency operating across all three cannot assume one state’s reporting satisfies another, because the timing, the recipient and the contents all differ.
Which of IS18, VPDSS and SACSF is the strictest?
They are strict in different ways, so there is no single ranking. IS18 is the most prescriptive on frameworks, because it mandates both ISO 27001 and the Essential Eight rather than leaving the method open. The VPDSS is the most legally grounded, issued under privacy legislation by an information commissioner who also regulates it, which gives it a statutory weight the others do not have. The SACSF is the most integrated, operating inside a broader protective security framework that also covers personnel and physical security.
On the specific measure of Essential Eight maturity, all three are lighter than New South Wales and Western Australia, because none sets a mandatory level. Strictness depends on what is being measured: prescription of method, legal enforceability, or breadth of coverage. For an organisation trying to comply, the practical point is that each state expects a genuine, evidenced security program, and the differences are in how that program is framed and reported rather than in how seriously each state takes it. The full set of state frameworks is compared in the state cyber security frameworks overview.
What does this mean for suppliers across Queensland, Victoria and South Australia?
A supplier working across the three states has to meet each agency’s flowed down requirements separately, because none of the frameworks recognises another. Evidence prepared for a Queensland department will not automatically satisfy a Victorian or South Australian one.
The good news is that the shared foundation does most of the work. A supplier with an ISO 27001 management system and demonstrable Essential Eight maturity is well placed in all three, because Queensland mandates ISO 27001, Victoria’s standards map to it, and South Australia draws on it, while the Essential Eight is recognised across the board. What changes state to state is the reporting wrapper and the specific classification and control expectations, which apply on top of that foundation. So the efficient approach for a multi state supplier is to build one strong security program on ISO 27001 and the Essential Eight, then handle each state’s specific requirements as an overlay. For a supplier working out how to meet requirements across several states, Cybernion helps through ISO 27001 and Essential Eight advisory and assessment.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between IS18, the VPDSS and the SACSF?
Queensland’s IS18 is built on an ISO 27001 information security management system with the Essential Eight mandated. Victoria’s VPDSS is twelve outcome based standards under the Privacy and Data Protection Act 2014, administered by an information commissioner. South Australia’s SACSF is eighteen policy statements over four protective security principles, falling under the state protective security framework. They share the goal of protecting government information but differ in structure, legal basis and how prescriptive they are.
How do IS18, VPDSS and SACSF treat the Essential Eight?
Queensland’s IS18 mandates the Essential Eight but sets the target maturity by risk. Victoria’s VPDSS does not mandate the Essential Eight at all, taking an outcome and risk based approach anchored to ISO 27001. South Australia’s SACSF has agencies report Essential Eight maturity in the annual attestation but sets no required level. So none of the three fixes an Essential Eight maturity floor the way New South Wales and Western Australia do.
How do reporting and attestation compare across the three frameworks?
Queensland’s IS18 requires an annual information security return by 30 September with an accountable officer attestation. Victoria’s VPDSS uses a biennial Protective Data Security Plan submitted to the information commissioner, with an annual attestation in between. South Australia’s SACSF requires an annual attestation collated by Treasury and Finance. All three put a senior officer’s signature behind the result, but the cadence and recipient differ across the three states.
Which of IS18, VPDSS and SACSF is the strictest?
They are strict in different ways rather than on a single scale. IS18 is the most prescriptive on frameworks, mandating both ISO 27001 and the Essential Eight. The VPDSS is the most legally grounded, issued under privacy legislation by an information commissioner with its own regulator. The SACSF is the most integrated into a broader protective security regime. None fixes an Essential Eight maturity level, so on that specific measure all three are lighter than New South Wales and Western Australia.
Written by Gaurav Vikash, an ASD endorsed IRAP assessor and senior cyber security leader with 18 years of experience across Australia, the UK and Asia, including CISO and senior security leadership roles. He holds CISSP, CISA, CISM and CRISC and is an ISO 27001 Lead Auditor and ISO 42001 Lead Implementer, and speaks regularly at industry conferences.
Sources:
- Information and cyber security policy (IS18), Queensland Government, June 2026
- Victorian Protective Data Security Standards, Office of the Victorian Information Commissioner, October 2019
- South Australian Cyber Security Framework, Office of the Chief Information Officer, June 2025
- Essential Eight, Australian Signals Directorate, 2026
Last updated: 30 August, 2026
