CIS Controls
CIS Controls vs Essential Eight: Which Should You Use?
3 July 2026 · Updated 3 July 2026
The CIS Controls are a broad global baseline of 18 controls and 153 safeguards; the Essential Eight is eight targeted technical mitigations the Australian Signals Directorate mandates for government. The CIS Controls cover far more, the Essential Eight goes deeper on its eight. CIS publishes an official mapping between the two, so they work together rather than competing.
This is not really a versus. One is a whole program, while the other is a mandated subset of technical controls. The real question is which one an organisation is measured against, and by whom.
What is the difference between the CIS Controls and the Essential Eight?
The core difference is scope. The CIS Critical Security Controls (CIS Controls) are a broad baseline of 18 controls and 153 safeguards published by the Center for Internet Security (CIS), covering everything from asset inventory to incident response and staff training. The Essential Eight is eight technical mitigation strategies the Australian Signals Directorate (ASD) publishes to harden internet connected, Microsoft Windows based networks.
The CIS Controls describe a full security program, while the Essential Eight describes a specific defensive floor: application control, patching, macro restrictions, application hardening, admin privilege restriction, operating system patching, multi factor authentication and backups. Every one of those maps to something in the CIS Controls, but the CIS Controls also cover governance, service provider risk, logging and awareness that the Essential Eight never touches. So they are not competitors of the same kind: one is the map, the other is a marked route through part of it.
How do the CIS Controls and the Essential Eight compare?
The CIS Controls and the Essential Eight compare across scope, authority, measurement and mandate, and they differ on each.
| Dimension | CIS Controls | Essential Eight |
|---|---|---|
| Set by | Center for Internet Security (global non profit) | Australian Signals Directorate |
| Scope | 18 controls, 153 safeguards, whole program | 8 technical mitigations for Windows IT networks |
| Structure | Three Implementation Groups (IG1 to IG3) | Four maturity levels (Zero to Three) |
| Focus | Broad: governance, people, process, technology | Narrow: technical hardening and recovery |
| Measurement | Safeguards implemented per Implementation Group | Maturity level per strategy, by assessment |
| Mandate in Australia | Voluntary best practice | Mandatory for non corporate Commonwealth entities |
| Entry point | IG1, 56 safeguards | All eight at Maturity Level One |
The pattern is clear. The CIS Controls trade depth on any single control for breadth across the whole program. The Essential Eight trades breadth for a demanding, well defined depth on eight things that stop the most common attacks on Australian networks.
Do the CIS Controls map to the Essential Eight?
Yes. CIS publishes an official document, CIS Controls v8.1 Mapping to ASD Essential Eight, released in March 2025, that maps each CIS safeguard to the relevant Essential Eight strategy. This means an organisation implementing the CIS Controls can see exactly which of its safeguards satisfy which Essential Eight mitigations, and where gaps remain.
The mapping is useful, but it has a limit. It shows that a CIS safeguard addresses the same subject as an Essential Eight strategy, yet it does not prove that a strategy has been implemented to the depth the Essential Eight maturity model requires. The Essential Eight scores how well each mitigation is done, from Maturity Level Zero to Three, and a matching CIS safeguard does not automatically clear Maturity Level Two. Treat the mapping as a coverage guide, not a compliance certificate.
Should an Australian organisation choose the CIS Controls or the Essential Eight?
For most Australian organisations the answer is both, in a specific order. For any organisation that sells to or operates within the Commonwealth government, the Essential Eight is not a choice. Non corporate Commonwealth entities must implement all eight strategies to at least Maturity Level Two, and the same expectation flows down through contracts and tenders to their suppliers. That obligation is fixed regardless of what else a business runs.
The CIS Controls then earn their place as the broader program around that mandated core. Many organisations run the CIS Controls internally to cover the governance, monitoring, third party and awareness work the Essential Eight ignores, and use the CIS to Essential Eight mapping to show a government buyer that their broader program already covers the eight. For an organisation choosing its first framework rather than layering, how to choose a cyber security framework in Australia walks through the decision. An Essential Eight assessment is what proves the mandated part.
Where do the CIS Controls fit for a government supplier?
For a government supplier, the CIS Controls fit as the internal engine and the Essential Eight as the external proof. The buyer sets the framework. A Commonwealth department asks for Essential Eight maturity, sometimes alongside the Information Security Manual through an IRAP assessment, so those are the things a supplier must demonstrate. The CIS Controls are rarely named in an Australian government contract.
That does not make them irrelevant. Running the CIS Controls gives a supplier a coherent program that produces most of the Essential Eight as a by product and covers the wider risks a maturity assessment never looks at. The sensible structure is CIS Controls as the standing program, Essential Eight and ISM as the assessed outputs. Where a supplier also sells to enterprise or overseas customers, a certifiable standard like ISO 27001 usually belongs beside all of this.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between the CIS Controls and the Essential Eight?
The CIS Controls are a broad global baseline of 18 controls and 153 safeguards from the Center for Internet Security. The Essential Eight is a narrow set of eight technical mitigations from the Australian Signals Directorate. The CIS Controls cover far more ground, but the Essential Eight is what Australian government suppliers are measured against.
Do the CIS Controls cover the Essential Eight?
Largely, yes. CIS publishes an official mapping showing how CIS Controls v8.1 safeguards align to the Essential Eight. Most Essential Eight mitigations correspond to CIS safeguards, though the Essential Eight demands a depth of implementation, scored by maturity level, that the CIS mapping does not fully capture.
Should an Australian organisation use the CIS Controls or the Essential Eight?
An organisation that sells to Australian government is measured against the Essential Eight, so that is not optional. Many organisations use the CIS Controls as the broader internal program and treat the Essential Eight as the specific technical baseline they must prove.
Is the Essential Eight or the CIS Controls harder to implement?
They are hard in different ways. The Essential Eight is only eight mitigations but demanding at Maturity Level Two and above. The CIS Controls span 153 safeguards but allow a start at IG1 with 56, so the breadth is larger while the entry point is gentler.
Can we be compliant with both the CIS Controls and the Essential Eight?
Yes, and many organisations are. Because the two overlap heavily on technical hardening, implementing the CIS Controls covers much of the Essential Eight. A separate Essential Eight maturity assessment is still needed to prove compliance for government purposes.
Written by Gaurav Vikash, an ASD endorsed IRAP assessor and senior cyber security leader with 18 years of experience across Australia, the UK and Asia, including CISO and senior security leadership roles. He holds CISSP, CISA, CISM and CRISC and is an ISO 27001 Lead Auditor and ISO 42001 Lead Implementer, and speaks regularly at industry conferences.
Sources:
- CIS Controls v8.1 Mapping to ASD Essential Eight, Center for Internet Security, 17 March 2025
- The 18 CIS Critical Security Controls, Center for Internet Security, accessed 3 July 2026
- Essential Eight maturity model, Australian Signals Directorate, accessed 3 July 2026
- Essential Eight explained, Australian Signals Directorate, accessed 3 July 2026
Last updated: 3 July, 2026
